Eating Disorder Risk
Prevalence of eating disorders and body image concerns among youth
12 September 08
Last year, I worked with two colleagues at the
University of Minnesota (Jayne Fulkerson, PhD of the
School of Nursing and Dianne Neumark-Sztainer, PhD,
MPH, RD of the Division of Epidemiology and Community
Health, School of Public Health) to understand the
probable prevalence of full threshold and
subthreshold eating disorders, as well as body image
concerns, among teenagers. Using the Project EAT
(Eating Among Teens) dataset which includes 4,746
students from Minnesota public middle and high
schools, we found that 43% of girls and 34% of boys
reported some significant level of disordered eating
and/or body image concerns.
Even though the rates of full threshold eating disorder diagnoses were low (2.3% for girls and 0.5% for boys), an alarmingly high percentage of youth reported binge eating, self-induced vomiting, laxative use and/or excessive exercise (16.0% girls, 15.4% boys) not meeting criteria for a full threshold eating disorder. An even higher proportion reported severe body disparagement without disordered eating behaviors (25.1% girls and 17.7% boys).
Our findings are concerning. There are many youth who report disordered eating behaviors and body disparagement severe enough to warrant treatment but not (yet) meeting criteria for an eating disorder, and who may have difficulty accessing treatment due to how diagnostic criteria inform insurance coverage and access to specialized treatment. We are missing a substantial opportunity to provide primary prevention, and certainly early intervention, to these vulnerable youth because it is currently difficult for them to access specialized care. As a revision to the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual is underway and anticipated to be published in 2011, we hope that these findings will be taken into consideration so that more affected individuals can access specialized treatment before developing a full threshold eating disorder.
This article can be accessed through the International Journal of Eating Disorders (Int J Eat Disorder 2007; 40: 409-417).
Even though the rates of full threshold eating disorder diagnoses were low (2.3% for girls and 0.5% for boys), an alarmingly high percentage of youth reported binge eating, self-induced vomiting, laxative use and/or excessive exercise (16.0% girls, 15.4% boys) not meeting criteria for a full threshold eating disorder. An even higher proportion reported severe body disparagement without disordered eating behaviors (25.1% girls and 17.7% boys).
Our findings are concerning. There are many youth who report disordered eating behaviors and body disparagement severe enough to warrant treatment but not (yet) meeting criteria for an eating disorder, and who may have difficulty accessing treatment due to how diagnostic criteria inform insurance coverage and access to specialized treatment. We are missing a substantial opportunity to provide primary prevention, and certainly early intervention, to these vulnerable youth because it is currently difficult for them to access specialized care. As a revision to the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual is underway and anticipated to be published in 2011, we hope that these findings will be taken into consideration so that more affected individuals can access specialized treatment before developing a full threshold eating disorder.
This article can be accessed through the International Journal of Eating Disorders (Int J Eat Disorder 2007; 40: 409-417).
Eating Disorder Support Groups in Twin Cities, MN
08 August 08
I was recently informed of two opportunities for
support groups for those struggling against eating
disorders. One is offered in Minneapolis, the other
in St Paul, and both are sponsored by The Joy Project. Individuals
who are currently affected by an eating disorder
or body image issues are encouraged to attend.
Mondays, 6:30 - 8:00 pm
University Lutheran Church of Hope
601 - 13th Avenue SE
Minneapolis MN 55414-1437
Thursdays, 6:30 - 8:00 pm
Central Park United Methodist Church
639 Jackson Street
St Paul, MN 55101
Mondays, 6:30 - 8:00 pm
University Lutheran Church of Hope
601 - 13th Avenue SE
Minneapolis MN 55414-1437
Thursdays, 6:30 - 8:00 pm
Central Park United Methodist Church
639 Jackson Street
St Paul, MN 55101
Eating Disorder Research Opportunities
27 February 08
The following research
opportunities were listed at the University of
Minnesota Powell
Center for Women's Health website:
ANOREXIA NERVOSA DIARY STUDY
Female volunteers ages 18 and older with symptoms of Anorexia Nervosa are needed for a study at the University of Minnesota. This is not a treatment study. Compensation up to $200. For more information please call Nora Sandager/Recruitment line 612-627-1993 or email sand0692@umn.edu.
EATING DISORDER RESEARCH STUDY
Women ages 18 and older who struggle with binge eating and purging are needed for a research study providing free therapy. For more information about this University of Minnesota Study, please call 612-627-1991.
ANOREXIA NERVOSA DIARY STUDY
Female volunteers ages 18 and older with symptoms of Anorexia Nervosa are needed for a study at the University of Minnesota. This is not a treatment study. Compensation up to $200. For more information please call Nora Sandager/Recruitment line 612-627-1993 or email sand0692@umn.edu.
EATING DISORDER RESEARCH STUDY
Women ages 18 and older who struggle with binge eating and purging are needed for a research study providing free therapy. For more information about this University of Minnesota Study, please call 612-627-1991.
National Eating Disorders Awareness Week
27 February 08
Thursday night, 28 February from 7 - 10pm, Macalester
College (1600 Grand Avenue, St Paul 55105) will show
the HBO Documentary Film "Thin" and host a
discussion about the pervasiveness of the
problem of eating disorders and efforts that the
Macalester College community can take in
providing support to those struggling against
eating disorders. You do not need to be a
Macalester student, staff, or other affiliate to
attend - all are welcome.
Extreme versus Methodical Weight Management
04 January 08
With the new year comes resolutions for many people,
and one of the most common is related to weight. When
we combine our knowledge bases for prevention of
eating disorders (e.g., anorexia and bulimia nervosa)
and prevention of obesity and overweight, we
generally come up with the same list of strategies
for long-term, methodical weight management.
Combining regular treatment strategies for
individuals suffering against eating disorders with
the results from the National Weight Control
Registry, a longitudinal study of over 4000
overweight adults who have successfully maintained a
healthier weight for multiple years, we know that
successful weight management at a
healthy weight incorporates the
following strategies:
• eating breakfast every day, and eating regularly (4-5 times) throughout the day
• limiting the frequency of eating out at fast food establishments
• eating a lower-fat, higher-carbohydrate diet
• watching less than 10 hours of television per week
• exercising, on average, about 1 hour per day at a moderate level (e.g., walking, aerobics class, biking, swimming)
• self-monitoring weight, portion sizes, and meal practices
These practices may be appropriate for individuals who are overweight by medical standards or who seek to maintain a current healthy weight. Note that extreme measures, such as overexercising, skipping meals, or using harmful measures such as laxatives or diet pills were not listed as successful strategies. In fact, the use of extreme measures may affect basal metabolic rate in such a manner that weight is gained over time! So, treat your body well with a daily, methodical, and moderate weight management plan.
• eating breakfast every day, and eating regularly (4-5 times) throughout the day
• limiting the frequency of eating out at fast food establishments
• eating a lower-fat, higher-carbohydrate diet
• watching less than 10 hours of television per week
• exercising, on average, about 1 hour per day at a moderate level (e.g., walking, aerobics class, biking, swimming)
• self-monitoring weight, portion sizes, and meal practices
These practices may be appropriate for individuals who are overweight by medical standards or who seek to maintain a current healthy weight. Note that extreme measures, such as overexercising, skipping meals, or using harmful measures such as laxatives or diet pills were not listed as successful strategies. In fact, the use of extreme measures may affect basal metabolic rate in such a manner that weight is gained over time! So, treat your body well with a daily, methodical, and moderate weight management plan.
Effects of Abuse on Binge-Eating and Purging
26 October 07
Collaborations with my colleagues at the University
of Minnesota have allowed us to investigate several
factors on problems associated with sexual and
physical abuse (emotional abuse and neglect are
likely associated with the same problems, but weren't
included in the survey).
In 2001, we were discouraged when we learned that 18.1% of girls and 11.9% of the boys studied reported being physically and/or sexually abused. Abuse was significantly associated with binge-eating and purging behavior. It was further upsetting to learn that less than a third of abused youth chose to talk with someone about the abuse. Our findings suggested a trend toward those who talked with someone being less likely to engage in binge-eating and purging behavior. Of those who did decide to discuss their abuse, they most often turned to a close friend, a parent, or another trusted adult.
Sexual and physical violence have multiple negative effects, including but certainly not limited to eating disorder behaviors. Talking about the abuse may reduce shame and lessen emotional distress related to the abuse, however it's essential to find safe, trusting, and accessible environments and persons to approach about these difficult issues. If you or someone you know has been abused, please seek help from someone you trust.
In 2001, we were discouraged when we learned that 18.1% of girls and 11.9% of the boys studied reported being physically and/or sexually abused. Abuse was significantly associated with binge-eating and purging behavior. It was further upsetting to learn that less than a third of abused youth chose to talk with someone about the abuse. Our findings suggested a trend toward those who talked with someone being less likely to engage in binge-eating and purging behavior. Of those who did decide to discuss their abuse, they most often turned to a close friend, a parent, or another trusted adult.
Sexual and physical violence have multiple negative effects, including but certainly not limited to eating disorder behaviors. Talking about the abuse may reduce shame and lessen emotional distress related to the abuse, however it's essential to find safe, trusting, and accessible environments and persons to approach about these difficult issues. If you or someone you know has been abused, please seek help from someone you trust.
Family Meals and Eating Disorders: Findings for Empowering Change
18 August 07
Unfortunately, families have been an easy target for
blame when it comes to mental and behavioral health
problems among youth. Regardless of whether families
are part of the problem, they can be part of the
solution. In 2001, we published a paper on the
associations between family meal frequency and
symptoms of bulimia nervosa among 560 college-aged
females. Results were clear - the more frequently
families ate dinner together, the lower the scores on
measures of bulimic symptoms. In part, this reflects
a broader picture, in that those families who ate
together more frequently were also those that were
more cohesive, more likely to promote individuals
being self-sufficient, and less focused on
achievement in a competitive manner than those
families who ate together less frequently.
What are the recommendations based on these findings?
Families should be encouraged to eat together, taking into account barriers such as specific family environments and time factors. In families where frequent family meals are not feasible or could be detrimental due to the overall family functioning (e.g., in cases of violent families or families in which there is another member with an active eating disorder), children may benefit from spending time and eating meals with more appropriate role models.
What are the recommendations based on these findings?
Families should be encouraged to eat together, taking into account barriers such as specific family environments and time factors. In families where frequent family meals are not feasible or could be detrimental due to the overall family functioning (e.g., in cases of violent families or families in which there is another member with an active eating disorder), children may benefit from spending time and eating meals with more appropriate role models.
Empowering Youth Through Puberty
11 August 07
We already know that puberty is a difficult time for
all adolescents, given the myriad of physical
changes, social peer pressures, and academic
challenges. We can help adolescents navigate these
rough waters by providing them safe and open arenas
for airing their concerns, de-emphasizing the
importance of weight and shape, educating them on
strategies to challenge the media's portrayal of
thinness as the ideal body shape for females and
muscularity as the ideal body type for males, and
promoting healthy eating and regular exercise as part
of an overall positive lifestyle.
Is Puberty a Risk Factor for Eating Disorders, Poor Body Image?
03 August 07
I am perpetually interested in the factors that serve
to protect from, as well as those that increase risk
toward, the development of psychological problems.
While I believe that psychological diagnoses are a
combination between genetic predispositions and
environmental stressors, certain individuals and/or
populations may be at increased risk.
In 2001, my colleagues and I conducted a retrospective recall study of the effect of pubertal timing and perception of weight prior to puberty on eating disorder risk among more than 200 college-age females. We found that the perception of being overweight prior to entering puberty, but not age at onset of puberty, may be a risk factor for the later development of disordered eating concerns and behaviors, body image dissatisfaction, and related psychological problems. However, both age at onset of puberty and prepubertal weight perception were associated with greater emphasis on the importance of appearance and stronger drive for thinness, and poorer impulse control. Early maturers or those perceiving their prepubertal weight as overweight were more symptomatic.
In 2001, my colleagues and I conducted a retrospective recall study of the effect of pubertal timing and perception of weight prior to puberty on eating disorder risk among more than 200 college-age females. We found that the perception of being overweight prior to entering puberty, but not age at onset of puberty, may be a risk factor for the later development of disordered eating concerns and behaviors, body image dissatisfaction, and related psychological problems. However, both age at onset of puberty and prepubertal weight perception were associated with greater emphasis on the importance of appearance and stronger drive for thinness, and poorer impulse control. Early maturers or those perceiving their prepubertal weight as overweight were more symptomatic.
Adolescent Dating Violence: Study Findings
20 July 07
Because of my clinical work in eating disorders,
which predominantly affect younger individuals, I
have had the joy of working with many adolescents.
Yet I have been alarmed in hearing of numerous
unhealthy dating experiences, either their own or
those of their friends. Subsequently, one of my
primary areas of focus has been on adverse dating
experiences among adolescents.
• In 2002, we published the largest study to date on adolescent dating violence. In a survey of over 81,247 Minnesota youth, we found that a worrisome 9% of girls and 6% of boys had experienced either physical or sexual violence by a dating partner. Of further concern, dating violence was found to be associated with higher rates of disordered eating behaviors (such as binge-eating, fasting or skipping meals, taking diet pills, self-induced vomiting, and taking laxatives) and suicidal thoughts and attempts, and lower scores on measures of emotional well-being and self-esteem. Visit the American Psychological Association's press release for this article.
• In 2003, we published a follow-up study of over 3,000 youth who completed the Commonwealth Fund Survey of the Health of Adolescent Boys and Girls. With this nationally representative population-based sample, and using a different definition of physical or sexual violence by a dating partner, our findings showed that an alarmingly high 17% of girls and 9% of boys reported adolescent dating violence. Dating violence was found to be associated with a broad range of behavioral and mental health risks, including dieting, binge-eating and purging behaviors, cigarette smoking, alcohol consumption, drug use, suicidal thoughts, depression, and poorer self-esteem for both girls and boys. Of particular concern was our finding that approximately 50% of girls and boys who had experienced physical and sexual dating violence also reported staying in relationships out of fear of physical harm.
• In 2002, we published the largest study to date on adolescent dating violence. In a survey of over 81,247 Minnesota youth, we found that a worrisome 9% of girls and 6% of boys had experienced either physical or sexual violence by a dating partner. Of further concern, dating violence was found to be associated with higher rates of disordered eating behaviors (such as binge-eating, fasting or skipping meals, taking diet pills, self-induced vomiting, and taking laxatives) and suicidal thoughts and attempts, and lower scores on measures of emotional well-being and self-esteem. Visit the American Psychological Association's press release for this article.
• In 2003, we published a follow-up study of over 3,000 youth who completed the Commonwealth Fund Survey of the Health of Adolescent Boys and Girls. With this nationally representative population-based sample, and using a different definition of physical or sexual violence by a dating partner, our findings showed that an alarmingly high 17% of girls and 9% of boys reported adolescent dating violence. Dating violence was found to be associated with a broad range of behavioral and mental health risks, including dieting, binge-eating and purging behaviors, cigarette smoking, alcohol consumption, drug use, suicidal thoughts, depression, and poorer self-esteem for both girls and boys. Of particular concern was our finding that approximately 50% of girls and boys who had experienced physical and sexual dating violence also reported staying in relationships out of fear of physical harm.